NAFTA and Mexican Migration To Michigan
and the U.S.

by

Robert Aponte

Working Paper No. 25

July 14, 1995

 

Among the key selling points of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) was the notion that the economic benefits of treaty's passage would slow Mexico-US migration. Whatever the ultimate extent of NAFTA's economic consequences, it is argued here that the treaty's implementation will stimulate more migration than it will stem. This is because neither the quality nor the quantity of the NAFTA-induced jobs on the Mexican side, the key ingredient in the migration-supression hypothesis, will be sufficient to deter many northern bound labor migrants. In addition, the economic integration process itself will entail job-losses in Mexico that will stimulate increased migration. On balance, therefore, outmigration will increase, rather than decrease.

Despite this prediction, it is also argued here that Michigan, while sure to remain among the states most actively involved in financial dealings with Mexico, is not likely to be among the major receivers of the enhanced migration streams. Michigan will host little increased migration because most such migrants are likely to enter via existing trajectories which currently funnel large numbers of migrants. The best data available suggest that very little direct immigration from Mexico is currently steered toward Michigan. For example, the Mexican-origin population in the state grew at a very low rate during the 1980s, a decade of record Mexican immigration, and only a portion of this growth could have been due to migration. Indeed, in absolute terms, the state's Mexican-origin population grew faster in the 1970s than the 1980s, and it is likely that the portion of the growth due to migration came largely from other parts of the US, rather than from Mexico.

Hardcopy Price: $3.00

 

View the full report in
HTML format
(with your web browser).
 

Download the report in PDF
(Acrobat Reader) format to view/print on
your personal computer (size: 65K).

 

Please Note:

To download and view the publications in PDF format, you will need the Adobe Acrobat Reader software on your machine. You can download the software for free by clicking on the appropriate system you have: Windows or Mac OS.

All JSRI Publications are also available in hard copies, at the prices specified. For any orders or further information please send an email to: info@jsri.msu.edu.

 

JSRI Home | JSRI Research & Publications | Working Paper Series


webmaster@jsri.msu.edu

 

 

JSRI Home

 For more information, contact:
Julian Samora Research Institute
Michigan State University
301 Nisbet Building
1407 S. Harrison
East Lansing, MI 48823-5286
Phone (517) 432-1317
Facsimile (517) 432-2221
E-mail info@jsri.msu.edu